Shows like Sherlock
Brilliant investigators and the relationships that complicate their work.
Starting with Sherlock (2010)
Title details on TMDB ↗
What should I watch after Sherlock?
For Sherlock fans, these three shows offer different ways forward: Elementary (A different Holmes and Watson); Luther (Intuition with a personal cost); Broadchurch (A case that changes a town). Each comparison below explains the connection and where the experience differs.
Sherlock makes deduction a performance, but its partnership gives the performance stakes. The next show might preserve Holmes and Watson in a different form, put an intuitive investigator under moral pressure, or move the emphasis from a brilliant individual to the community affected by a crime.
Elementary is the closest character reinterpretation, Luther the most intense personal thriller, and Broadchurch the most community-centered mystery. They differ in episode structure as well as tone, so choose according to how much continuing case work you want.
Which direction interests you?
Start with the connection you want, then read the differences before choosing.
Elementary
A modern Holmes and Watson investigate cases in New York with a different partnership at the center.
Title details on TMDB ↗Why it connects
Elementary reworks the familiar investigative partnership around recovery, professional trust, and a changing balance between its leads. It is the direct choice for viewers who want more deduction alongside a relationship that develops through work.
Where it differs
New York and a larger case-of-the-week structure distinguish it from Sherlock’s compact seasons. The partnership is less theatrical and more gradually collaborative.
Luther
An intense London detective drama puts obsession and personal judgment under pressure.
Title details on TMDB ↗Why it connects
Luther follows a detective whose intensity makes professional boundaries unstable. It connects through an investigator who seems able to reach difficult truths while struggling to manage the relationships and impulses surrounding the work.
Where it differs
The atmosphere is darker and the threats frequently more brutal. Psychological pursuit matters more than displaying a neatly explained chain of deductions.
Broadchurch
A coastal community becomes the focus of a carefully observed murder investigation.
Title details on TMDB ↗Why it connects
Broadchurch pairs investigators while showing how a death spreads suspicion through familiar relationships. Choose it when you want the emotional consequences behind the clues rather than only the pleasure of a clever solution.
Where it differs
A sustained central investigation replaces most standalone puzzles. Its grief and community portrait move at a more deliberate pace.
These are editorial comparisons of themes, tone, and storytelling, rather than a numerical ranking or personalized results. Title identities were checked against the linked catalog or publisher records on October 25, 2026. The connections and differences are Resonami’s analysis. Sources provide title context; availability and editions can vary. Read our editorial approach and corrections policy.
Dates distinguish the film or original series being discussed. A similar premise can still mean a very different level of violence or intensity.